Table of Contents
With interest rates at their highest levels in over two decades, savers finally have meaningful options for growing their cash reserves. But the choice between high-yield savings accounts (HYSA) and certificates of deposit (CDs) isn't always straightforward. Each has distinct advantages depending on your financial goals, timeline, and need for liquidity.
Quick Overview: HYSA vs CDs
Before diving into the details, here's a quick comparison of the two savings vehicles:
| Feature | High-Yield Savings | Certificate of Deposit |
|---|---|---|
| Current APY Range | 4.25% - 5.30% | 4.50% - 5.50% |
| Access to Funds | Unlimited (6 withdrawals/month) | Locked until maturity |
| Early Withdrawal Penalty | None | 3-12 months of interest |
| Rate Stability | Variable (can change anytime) | Fixed for term length |
| Minimum Deposit | $0 - $100 | $500 - $10,000 |
| FDIC Insured | Yes, up to $250,000 | Yes, up to $250,000 |
Current Rates Comparison (January 2024)
Here's what top financial institutions are offering:
Best High-Yield Savings Accounts
| Bank | APY | Min. Balance | Monthly Fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marcus by Goldman Sachs | 4.50% | $0 | None |
| Ally Bank | 4.25% | $0 | None |
| Discover Bank | 4.30% | $0 | None |
| Capital One 360 | 4.30% | $0 | None |
| SoFi Money | 4.60% | $0 | None |
Best CD Rates by Term
| Term | Best Rate | Bank | Min. Deposit |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 months | 5.30% | Popular Direct | $10,000 |
| 1 year | 5.50% | CFG Bank | $500 |
| 2 years | 5.20% | LendingClub | $2,500 |
| 3 years | 4.85% | First Internet Bank | $1,000 |
| 5 years | 4.50% | Discover Bank | $2,500 |
When to Choose a High-Yield Savings Account
A high-yield savings account is the better choice in these scenarios:
1. Emergency Fund Storage
Your emergency fund should always be in a HYSA, not a CD. Why? Because emergencies don't follow a schedule. You need immediate access without penalties. Financial experts recommend 3-6 months of expenses in an easily accessible account.
2. Saving for Short-Term Goals
If you're saving for a goal within the next 12 months—a wedding, vacation, or car purchase—a HYSA provides flexibility. You can add money anytime and withdraw when needed without penalties.
3. When Rates Are Rising
In a rising rate environment, locking into a fixed-rate CD means missing out on better returns. HYSA rates typically increase alongside Fed rate hikes, allowing you to benefit from rising yields.
4. Irregular Income
Freelancers, commission-based workers, or anyone with variable income needs liquidity. A HYSA accommodates irregular deposits without restrictions.
💡 Pro Tip: The HYSA + CD Hybrid Strategy
Keep 3 months of expenses in a HYSA for immediate access, and put the remaining 3 months in a 6-month CD for higher yield. This gives you both liquidity and better returns on your emergency fund.
When to Choose a Certificate of Deposit
CDs shine in these situations:
1. Known Timeline for Large Purchases
If you're buying a house in exactly 12 months and have your down payment saved, a 1-year CD locks in a guaranteed rate higher than any savings account.
2. When Rates Are Peaking
With the Fed potentially cutting rates in 2024, locking in current high rates with a CD could be smart. Once you're locked in, your rate doesn't decrease even if market rates fall.
3. Discipline for Long-Term Savings
The early withdrawal penalty acts as a deterrent against impulse spending. If you struggle with leaving savings untouched, a CD's lock-up period can help.
4. Laddering Strategy
CD laddering—opening multiple CDs with staggered maturity dates—provides regular access to portions of your money while maintaining higher overall yields.
⚠️ Important: Early Withdrawal Penalties
CD penalties vary by bank and term length. Typical penalties are:
- Terms under 1 year: 3 months of interest
- Terms 1-3 years: 6 months of interest
- Terms over 3 years: 12+ months of interest
Some banks offer "no-penalty CDs" with lower rates but full liquidity after 7 days.
Advanced Savings Strategies
The CD Ladder
Instead of putting $10,000 into one 5-year CD, split it:
- $2,000 in a 1-year CD
- $2,000 in a 2-year CD
- $2,000 in a 3-year CD
- $2,000 in a 4-year CD
- $2,000 in a 5-year CD
As each CD matures, reinvest in a new 5-year CD. After 5 years, you'll have a CD maturing every year, providing both liquidity and long-term rates.
Bump-Up CDs
Some banks offer "bump-up" CDs that let you increase your rate once during the term if rates rise. These typically offer slightly lower initial rates but provide valuable flexibility.
Brokered CDs
Available through brokerage accounts like Fidelity or Schwab, brokered CDs often offer higher rates and can be sold on the secondary market before maturity (though you may take a loss).
Interest Earnings Calculator
Use this calculator to compare potential earnings:
Our 2024 Recommendations
For Emergency Funds: High-Yield Savings
Your emergency fund belongs in a HYSA, period. The liquidity is worth the slightly lower rate. We recommend Marcus by Goldman Sachs (4.50% APY) or SoFi Money (4.60% APY) for their competitive rates and no minimums.
For Known Future Expenses: CDs
If you have a specific purchase timeline, lock in current rates with a CD. CFG Bank's 1-year CD at 5.50% APY is our top pick for 2024.
For Maximum Yield: CD Ladder
Build a 5-rung CD ladder with equal amounts in 1-5 year CDs. As rates potentially fall in 2024, you'll lock in today's high rates while maintaining annual liquidity.
Bottom Line
There's no one-size-fits-all answer. The best savers use both: HYSA for emergency funds and short-term goals, CDs for known expenses and rate-locking. In the current environment, a hybrid approach maximizes both yield and flexibility.